ISC.Org ANY Request DRDoS Update
It has been some time now since I started talking about the curious case of the isc.org ANY request flood (later revealed to be a UDP amplification attack) and our friends are still knocking at the gates hot and heavy. In the past couple of days I have noticed some particularly voluminous activity, culminating in this wave this afternoon.
ID Blocked IP Date Time Time Remaining 4000002 69.197.22.82 11/17/10 15:36:49 1d 00:00:00 4000002 72.20.9.147 11/17/10 15:35:31 23:58:42 4000002 72.20.9.154 11/17/10 15:24:38 23:47:49 4000002 95.168.172.188 11/17/10 15:24:01 23:47:12 4000002 85.195.105.91 11/17/10 15:22:31 23:45:42 4000002 72.20.9.150 11/17/10 15:19:21 23:42:32 4000002 84.16.227.96 11/17/10 15:15:08 23:38:19 4000002 78.159.121.149 11/17/10 15:13:21 23:36:32 4000002 178.162.182.250 11/17/10 15:11:02 23:34:13 4000002 72.20.9.156 11/17/10 15:10:21 23:33:32 4000002 78.159.99.146 11/17/10 15:07:53 23:31:04 4000002 78.129.164.142 11/17/10 15:05:57 23:29:08 4000002 78.159.107.219 11/17/10 15:05:13 23:28:24 4000002 72.20.9.149 11/17/10 15:04:32 23:27:43 4000002 206.217.216.249 11/17/10 15:02:50 23:26:01 4000002 95.154.240.8 11/17/10 15:00:38 23:23:49 4000002 72.20.56.237 11/17/10 14:58:20 23:21:31 4000002 78.159.108.198 11/17/10 14:50:12 23:13:23
Since the attacks are so frequent the IPS is having a hard time keeping up and enough packets are getting through that I have decided this is no longer amusing enough to keep tracking. At the bottom of this page is the netfilter panacea.
For the curious, this is what I have been seeing in my packet captures:
0000 00 16 3e cc 00 02 00 16 3e bb 00 02 08 00 45 00 ..>..... >.....E.
0010 05 dc b6 5b 20 00 40 11 a1 8a 00 00 00 00 48 14 ...[ .@. ......H.
0020 09 93 00 35 63 01 06 c7 8d 82 2a 39 81 00 00 01 ...5c... ..*9....
0030 00 00 00 08 00 0f 03 69 73 63 03 6f 72 67 00 00 .......i sc.org..
0040 ff 00 01 c0 0c 00 02 00 01 00 00 76 ac 00 0e 04 ........ ...v....
0050 73 66 62 61 06 73 6e 73 2d 70 62 c0 0c c0 0c 00 sfba.sns -pb.....
0060 02 00 01 00 00 76 ac 00 06 03 6f 72 64 c0 2a c0 .....v.. ..ord.*.
0070 0c 00 02 00 01 00 00 76 ac 00 06 03 61 6d 73 c0 .......v ....ams.
0080 2a c0 0c 00 02 00 01 00 00 76 ac 00 19 02 6e 73 *....... .v....ns
0090 03 69 73 63 0b 61 66 69 6c 69 61 73 2d 6e 73 74 .isc.afi lias-nst
00a0 04 69 6e 66 6f 00 c0 0c 00 2e 00 01 00 00 93 fe .info... ........
00b0 00 9b 00 02 05 02 00 00 a8 c0 4d 0a b9 03 4c e3 ........ ..M...L.
00c0 2c 03 38 79 03 69 73 63 03 6f 72 67 00 52 d3 b5 ,.8y.isc .org.R..
00d0 f4 98 f3 d6 75 d8 6c 8f 1b 95 b8 55 82 4b 1a ff ....u.l. ...U.K..
00e0 93 99 29 95 09 a4 d8 1f 46 8b c9 92 45 6c 72 05 ..)..... F...Elr.
00f0 96 28 a7 53 4c 8c d6 e6 a3 b2 4d d6 3d 45 8b be .(.SL... ..M.=E..
0100 c4 5b a5 2b f9 f1 95 3a 9a 66 02 d7 5e 58 f5 7a .[.+...: .f..^X.z
0110 f2 f3 d6 94 f1 da a6 2b e8 43 9a 86 71 48 a1 7b .......+ .C..qH.{
0120 2e e2 d2 1c a9 9f 68 61 66 11 43 ca 70 88 d9 a0 ......ha f.C.p...
0130 03 82 0f af d3 e8 46 f7 86 33 21 ae 01 b8 62 01 ......F. .3!...b.
0140 84 41 f1 fe 88 23 2d 9c 27 7a 36 6c b7 c0 9a 00 .A...#-. 'z6l....
0150 2b 00 01 00 01 3c bd 00 18 32 5c 05 01 98 21 13 +....< .. .2\...!.
0160 d0 8b 4c 6a 1d 9f 6a ee 1e 22 37 ae f6 9f 3f 97 ..Lj..j. ."7...?.
0170 59 c0 9a 00 2b 00 01 00 01 3c bd 00 24 32 5c 05 Y...+... .<..$2\.
0180 02 f1 e1 84 c0 e1 d6 15 d2 0e b3 c2 23 ac ed 3b ........ ....#..;
0190 03 c7 73 dd 95 2d 5f 0e b5 c7 77 58 6d e1 8d a6 ..s..-_. ..wXm...
01a0 b5 c0 9a 00 2e 00 01 00 01 3c bd 00 97 00 2b 07 ........ .<....+.
01b0 02 00 01 51 80 4c f6 79 3a 4c e3 f6 2a f0 9e 03 ...Q.L.y :L..*...
01c0 6f 72 67 00 64 1a d8 1f c6 51 40 a6 25 28 e7 b9 org.d... .Q@.%(..
01d0 21 c2 2a 4b 30 a0 e8 74 30 83 76 b2 52 eb 0c ec !.*K0..t 0.v.R...
01e0 e4 e2 4c 3f f1 0e ec 6d 3a d6 b7 d6 2e 4e a3 4a ..L?...m :....N.J
01f0 5d f6 ac 08 40 25 a5 de 0a 89 90 5d d9 c0 b3 d3 ]...@%.. ...]....
0200 ef 4b d0 8a c3 d5 c2 49 fa c4 c3 84 29 4e 4e 16 .K.....I ....)NN.
0210 47 2e 5c f4 09 9f c4 70 9d 2c 40 c2 63 4b 52 2a G.\....p .,@.cKR*
0220 14 5b 55 ef 54 9d cc 20 9b 71 61 f4 6e 88 84 49 .[U.T.. .qa.n..I
0230 2c f3 08 77 c4 f0 4d cf 54 ea 64 19 be d3 bf 6c ,..w..M. T.d....l
0240 cd c0 cb 2f c0 63 00 01 00 01 00 01 1f 6c 00 04 .../.c.. .....l..
0250 c7 fe 3f fe c0 63 00 1c 00 01 00 01 1f 6c 00 10 ..?..c.. .....l..
0260 20 01 05 00 00 2c 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 02 54 ....,.. .......T
0270 c0 51 00 01 00 01 00 00 93 fd 00 04 c7 06 01 1e .Q...... ........
0280 c0 51 00 1c 00 01 00 00 93 fd 00 10 20 01 05 00 .Q...... .... ...
0290 00 60 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 30 c0 3f 00 01 .`...... ...0.?..
02a0 00 01 00 00 93 fd 00 04 c7 06 00 1e c0 3f 00 1c ........ .....?..
02b0 00 01 00 00 93 fe 00 10 20 01 05 00 00 71 00 00 ........ ....q..
02c0 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 30 c0 25 00 01 00 01 00 00 .......0 .%......
02d0 76 ac 00 04 95 14 40 03 c0 25 00 1c 00 01 00 00 v.....@. .%......
02e0 76 ac 00 10 20 01 04 f8 00 00 00 02 00 00 00 00 v... ... ........
02f0 00 00 00 19 c0 51 00 2e 00 01 00 00 93 fd 00 9b .....Q.. ........
0300 00 01 05 04 00 00 a8 c0 4d 0a b9 03 4c e3 2c 03 ........ M...L.,.
0310 38 79 03 69 73 63 03 6f 72 67 00 bb dc f9 a8 90 8y.isc.o rg......
0320 58 9c 7a 62 dd 73 82 89 78 82 1d b2 d6 6f e6 e6 X.zb.s.. x....o..
0330 36 d1 af d5 a1 a7 ff d7 54 c8 70 f2 14 57 f9 89 6....... T.p..W..
0340 99 fa 4e cb 70 23 cd 56 cc dd 8f 5b a7 a7 b7 ad ..N.p#.V ...[....
0350 32 68 1b a1 c0 de 1b e5 a7 f8 7a 5c 57 1c 72 09 2h...... ..z\W.r.
0360 3f f4 1a 22 c1 9d d9 f7 28 91 b9 e2 17 09 f9 a2 ?..".... (.......
0370 52 89 a5 d8 7f 7f d9 ba 31 52 d0 53 f0 de a5 b2 R....... 1R.S....
0380 37 6e 30 fb 0c e4 0d 46 dc b6 f5 50 55 64 3d 32 7n0....F ...PUd=2
0390 ec 3d 26 41 fa 56 ad ad 20 13 29 c0 51 00 2e 00 .=&A.V.. .).Q...
03a0 01 00 00 93 fd 00 9b 00 1c 05 04 00 00 a8 c0 4d ........ .......M
03b0 0a b9 03 4c e3 2c 03 38 79 03 69 73 63 03 6f 72 ...L.,.8 y.isc.or
03c0 67 00 47 51 42 a0 24 40 77 c3 eb 0d 1d 92 8f 04 g.GQB.$@ w.......
03d0 78 3e b2 f6 e7 93 73 98 41 ae ea e2 60 87 97 65 x>....s. A...`..e
03e0 4f e5 45 d1 3f b6 c9 ad 3b 52 48 e3 f8 cd 81 cc O.E.?... ;RH.....
03f0 18 75 50 90 26 58 28 47 39 f5 b7 a7 7d 39 de aa .uP.&X(G 9...}9..
0400 69 59 d0 36 de 09 a9 10 33 2b 0c ad 51 4e e0 74 iY.6.... 3+..QN.t
0410 dc ab 35 6c 1b a9 0d c4 31 31 b9 b6 b5 f1 42 11 ..5l.... 11....B.
0420 ef 08 c6 4f 4f eb 32 d6 9b fb 85 7d 67 1c 3f 8d ...OO.2. ...}g.?.
0430 25 cc 50 c4 55 1f 40 2a 0e f8 db 78 38 8f 74 0f %.P.U.@* ...x8.t.
0440 58 65 c0 3f 00 2e 00 01 00 00 93 fd 00 9b 00 01 Xe.?.... ........
0450 05 04 00 00 a8 c0 4d 0a b9 03 4c e3 2c 03 38 79 ......M. ..L.,.8y
0460 03 69 73 63 03 6f 72 67 00 0d fd 01 af 6b 47 87 .isc.org .....kG.
0470 51 e1 92 82 64 82 f2 b4 27 36 d1 e5 55 79 21 14 Q...d... '6..Uy!.
0480 31 e9 78 e9 2a 64 b8 bc 1a 59 67 33 e0 cf 5d c6 1.x.*d.. .Yg3..].
0490 ac 30 be 9d 02 75 a0 1e 03 9e 40 46 63 9c b5 cc .0...u.. ..@Fc...
04a0 18 fb 81 6d ca f5 7b c3 35 ce 2e 7a ad 6c a3 6f ...m..{. 5..z.l.o
04b0 df 6f 14 4f ee 71 57 fe f3 96 d0 b0 7b 43 54 65 .o.O.qW. ....{CTe
04c0 cf c8 d1 56 4e 9b 62 82 32 b5 db 73 67 3b f1 35 ...VN.b. 2..sg;.5
04d0 02 19 3a 1c bd cc d5 ad 7c 23 2c 53 1a 8c 0a 45 ..:..... |#,S...E
04e0 eb 10 f2 83 21 68 f3 7d 7a c0 3f 00 2e 00 01 00 ....!h.} z.?.....
04f0 00 93 fe 00 9b 00 1c 05 04 00 00 a8 c0 4d 0a b9 ........ .....M..
0500 03 4c e3 2c 03 38 79 03 69 73 63 03 6f 72 67 00 .L.,.8y. isc.org.
0510 76 61 9f e1 a7 45 ee c6 78 71 d9 a2 a3 e0 20 56 va...E.. xq.... V
0520 d6 64 17 a7 25 d1 11 5b 51 80 50 24 c5 9f 4b 19 .d..%..[ Q.P$..K.
0530 fa 5c e3 6f e2 f2 ca 9e e9 c0 9d ee 13 f8 21 03 .\.o.... ......!.
0540 22 d9 58 54 92 48 5f 71 95 d7 f4 4b 94 d4 5f 54 ".XT.H_q ...K.._T
0550 bf 1e da c1 f4 95 35 28 75 8f 09 f8 6a 15 11 eb ......5( u...j...
0560 ef 86 99 6f 45 5b 37 4d bc c8 8c 2b de b7 fc 7c ...oE[7M ...+...|
0570 77 e5 15 06 b4 cd 03 66 6b 32 da aa c1 c1 f5 0f w......f k2......
0580 46 24 ea cb 9e 2b 2a 04 b7 2a d4 b7 3d be 58 23 F$...+*. .*..=.X#
0590 c0 25 00 2e 00 01 00 00 76 ac 00 9b 00 01 05 04 .%...... v.......
05a0 00 00 a8 c0 4d 0a b9 03 4c e3 2c 03 38 79 03 69 ....M... L.,.8y.i
05b0 73 63 03 6f 72 67 00 45 62 4e 36 4e c3 e8 69 a4 sc.org.E bN6N..i.
05c0 94 da 56 f0 6a 73 e5 1f 16 e0 56 c8 95 b4 83 0b ..V.js.. ..V.....
05d0 28 d1 dd 06 10 da da 0c 78 43 4b c0 60 09 88 26 (....... xCK.`..&
05e0 d8 36 8e a0 69 3a 7d cd 9e 31 .6..i:}. .1
The above seems to be a new version of the attack which makes use of fragmentation. It has a differing payload in each packet and comes in short waves. This one seems to be emanating (or targeting) mostly from the 72.20.9.0/24 block. It appears to be getting used in conjunction with the old request:
0000 00 16 3e bb 00 02 00 16 3e cc 00 02 08 00 45 00 ..>..... >.....E. 0010 00 40 a6 11 00 00 e8 11 2f 70 48 14 09 93 00 00 .@...... /pH..... 0020 00 00 63 01 00 35 00 2c 00 00 2a 39 01 00 00 01 ..c..5., ..*9.... 0030 00 00 00 00 00 01 03 69 73 63 03 6f 72 67 00 00 .......i sc.org.. 0040 ff 00 01 00 00 29 10 00 00 00 80 00 00 00 .....).. ......
Here is the magic rule my friends:
# iptables -A INPUT -p udp -m string --hex-string "|03697363036f726700|" --algo bm --to 65535 -j DROP
UPDATE Thanks to David (below) for pointing out --to (all ports) is inefficient and could interfere with legitimate traffic. Additionally, I was able to fix a problem resolving domains that involve .nl tld servers by broadening the pattern:
# iptables -A INPUT -p udp -m string --hex-string "|00000000000103697363036f726700|" --algo bm --to 65535 --dport 53 -j DROP
Comments
@Wil Barath
Quite right and you can read more about ACLs at http://foxpa.ws/2010/07/20/making-the-case-for-access-controlled-recursive-lookups-with-bind/
A better solution is to make your DNS server less attractive to attackers by denying recursive lookups to hosts outside your organization's networks.
This is easily achieved like so:
--
acl mynet { 127.0.0.1; ::1; 1.2.3.4/5; 12.34.56.78; };
options {
listen-on port 53 { 127.0.0.1; 192.168.0.xx; };
listen-on-v6 port 53 { ::1; };
allow-query { any; };
recursion yes;
allow-recursion { mynet; };
pid-file "/var/named/chroot/var/run/named/named.pid";
directory "/var/named/chroot/var/named";
auth-nxdomain no;
};
zone "." {
type hint;
file "named.ca";
};
---
etc. In the example, the net 1.2.3.4/5 would be a 32-ip public or private network block, and 12.34.56.78 would be a specific host address, for example your office's public-facing address if you use your own DNS server(s) to resolve lookups for your office.
To see how effective it is, make the changes, then restart the nameserver:
~# service named restart
Then start query logging:
~# rndc querylog
Then after a while grep the system log for query traffic log entries:
~# grep 'query:' /var/log/messages |tail -1000 |less
You should see a complete lack of abusive lookups being serviced. Once the botnets come to realise that your DNS server is no longer available as a tool to amplify their attacks on other hosts they will stop wasting their resources by way of querying your DNS server.
@sysadmin
Me too. The 'dot' in isc.org, as it comes across the wire, isn't ascii.
Thanks, this worked for me. Initially I tried with --string "isc.org", but with no luck.
iptables -t raw -I PREROUTING -p udp -m string --algo bm --hex-string "|0369 7363 036f 7267|" -j DROP
raw drop
I was hit with this in mid October. I had my ISP chasing down a problem... and they actually found a problem, fixed it... but I still had a problem. My network was saturated most of the time. So I started doing research and found a lot of traffic going to Bind. Some analysis showed me that certain DNS servers were overloading me with packets, so I started firewalling them off. I have reduced 99% of the traffic... except for one... and the traffic coming from that one server is not much. A sniff turned up "isc.org" inside the stream, which is a constanst flow of something small that is repeated over and over infinitely. It doesn't stop. I went to isc.org, and ironically, they appear to be a ligitmite organization dealing with DNS/Bind. And then a Google search turned up these blogs....
Hi,
Your iptables rule should probably contain a "--destination-port 53" otherwise netfilter would potentially process thousands/millions of UDP packets unnecessarily.
Best Wishes,
-David Delaune
Good point. I've made an addendum. Thanks.
Hi
One easier way to block is (for me) to block pakets with source port 80 or 53 with dest.port 53.
That way it will block any domains they use to make a any-query and any target-ip. Works for me :) I get spammed with port 80 and 53 as sourceport and they query both isc.org and ripe.net .
Interesting, I've seen a few different source ports now but all above 1024 so far.
@Luojie
They're not exactly attacking you, they're using your server to attack someone else. The "sending" address is spoofed so your server sends more traffic to it than the attacker sends to you. It is impossible to block by IP because the attacker just moves on to a new target. You must use the netfilter rule I provided at the end of this article to block their request packets from reaching your server based on the contents of the payload regardless of the source address.
Hi, this lamer is attacking my server, so I switched to stealth. As fast as I block his IP, he comes back on another. There really are some sad sacks of s... on the web?